Cardiology vs neurosurgery reddit. CT Surgery is a pretty well developed field.

Cardiology vs neurosurgery reddit neurology are not the same. pagkatapos niyang pumili, dumating yung attending. 5-2. doc saw the patient, explained the cost and told the patient he cant afford him. Academics seems to be ~200-230k starting. Feel free to ask w any questions What practice model and area of interest within neurosurgery and CT would allow for a better work/life balance and what would ensure a bad work/life balance? but I would venture to say that CT has (maybe) a slightly better than neurosurgery during residency/fellowship, and then probably a worse lifestyle than NSG as an attending First, IM is very diffent from surgical specialties due to the number of applicants and initial competition to enter. you will be taking 10 days of call per month on top of doing clinic those same days, that's almost a third of the month. The mortality rate is much higher, up to 20 to 30 percent with some emergency open heart operations eg ruptured thoracic aneurysms. 3rd yr medical student torn between Radiology & NeuroSurgery. I say not the neurosurgery route because generally it is a 8-10 year training. I am not in the medical profession so I would really appreciate any advice on which one I should get him - the Cardiology IV or the Master Cardiology. Structural Cardiology vs Interventional Cardiology Hey guys, I noticed that for multiple different institutions there are now two different fellowships for structural and interventional cardiology. Jan 8, 2018 · Cardiac is hardest: While neurosurgeons might protest, the training for cardiac surgery is much longer. Neurosurgery residency (7 years), NIR fellowship (2 years) Radiology residency (5 years), diagnostic neuro fellowship (1 year), NIR fellowship (2 years) Academic NIR generally approaches 100% NIR; private practice is more often a mix with the other portion made up by neurosurgery, neurology clinic, or diagnostic neuro. If neurointerventional is what you’re set on, I would not recommend neurosurgery route. There isn't much room to do new research compared to fields like neurosurgery. r/medicine is a virtual lounge for physicians and other medical professionals from around the world to talk about the latest advances, controversies, ask questions of each other, have a laugh, or share a difficult moment. such coldness. In by 4am, done by 8pm with one overnight call day per week. Current rankings so far: Northwell Long Island (Northshore LIJ) Stony Brook Starting med school in a few weeks and wondering which stethoscope to get. CTS had a bit of a reckoning 15 or so years ago when percutaneous coronary intervention stole the butter off their bread and EWTD came in - unlike neurosurgery, they acted and instituted heavy workforce monitoring and hired more ACPs to support the SpR tier. Switched into family med. Rarely you'll get a massive PE. Trivial hyperglycemia I'm a CHF patient? Endo consult. Jan 1, 2021 · Now I am totally undecided about what to do and have a few days to decide. My school recommends the cardiology IV, but I've heard that a lot of people use the classic and can't tell a big difference. Well location par hai. This is a virtual lounge for doctors practicing in the Philippines. In my experience, Cardiology consults for every non-cardiac problem, to a depressing extent. I've considered interventional cardiology, but it seems like stents are really only useful in acute coronary syndromes, and not for much else. But IRs already ceded turf to neurosurgery and it seems that neurosurgery is in the driver's seat right now. Some cardiologists choose to pursue additional training in subspecialties like interventional cardiology, heart failure, or electrophysiology. neurosurgery ops are not short either, so if you have any add on cases that's potentially 3-5 hours for spine Cardiology is a fellowship so if I wanna go into cardiology I would match internal medicine. A medschool acquaintance was a super neurosurgery gunner. You ask for help so other people can to. Cardiology involves a three-year internal medicine residency and a cardiology fellowship. Training is of course tough but the attending life seems reasonable depending on your ultimate practice: academic vs private, inpatient vs outpatient, and call schedule. Welcome to r/neurology home of science-based neurology for physicians, neuroscientists, and fans of neurology. My neurologist almost always tries to refer me to cardiology for my POTS because she doesn’t necessarily understand it as much as others do - her specialty is more migraines + neurosurgery. four hospitals is potentially a LOT of patients to round on, not even considering time to and from each. I work inpatient but as a specialty it's fantastic. grabe. But my bigger point is that there is a huge difference between matching into cardiology at any program vs not matching cardiology at all then there is between matching cardiology at a random program vs a prestigious program. Hard to summarize in a Reddit comment. My mentor (neurosurgeon) sat me down right before I was about to apply, told me that if I could see myself doing any other specialty, to do that instead. In my opinion, the worst lifestyle out of all specialties. Is this a new delineation or some thing that I just wasn’t aware of? Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now. If you're with cardiology, you'll mostly see heart failure and MI. I personally would go the radiology route over neurology because I believe you have to do a vascular neurology fellowship for that prior to interventional fellowship. I’d be tempted if I was there. They exist for everything from Caths, to echoes, to ecgs, to consults. If you're with endo, you'll mostly see diabetes. It's even true of family med: you'll mostly see cholesterol, blood pressure, and diabetes checkups. This can impact VS aka Neuro sending pts to neurosurgery for CEAs , but IR is a lot more exposed. Well I recently started: Non academic medical group Chicago suburbs Goal is 14 patients per day while also reading echo/nuc/stress/ekg and rounding on my own patients at hospital One week in five on inpatient consults One half day supervising stresses at hospital 1 call night every other week $370k two year guarantee - combo of production and other metrics after that - many noninvasive He is a final year student (going onto Foundation training in July next year) and is talking about possibly focusing on cardiology during his subsequent Internal Medicine training. Like the closest we will get another is potentially in 2020 so we have a lot of cardiology or interventional radiology doing our stuff. It's a square peg round hold situation. It requires board certification in both general and thoracic surgery and is far more intense. Topics include multiple sclerosis, seizures/epilepsy, stroke, peripheral neurology, anatomy of the brain and nerves, parkinson's disease, huntington's disease, syncope, medical treatments, ALS, carpal tunnel syndrome, vertigo, migraines, cluster headaches, and more. My friends in neurosurgery work more than me but they are geniuses and love what they are doing. Cool surgeries though. It's buying time for the patient to get better. ENT: Cummings vs. For a bit of context, I thought I was dead set on cardiology for all my life and then I had my anesthesia rotation coupled with a few weeks of ICU + Cardiac anesthesia. It seems to me like path and primary care compensation are pretty similar these days Hemodynamics, by far, is going to be better served by cardiology. By the middle of MS3 year I had ruled out everything except for my original 3 - ophtho, ENT, IM. So many young IC will have to do a lot of general cardiology time. However, I have recently gained a huge interest in the world of cardiology. Also there’s much bigger cons, such as cluster B personalities making your life a living hell, stubborn and lying addicts, and psychotherapy is just one modality. For the USA, after you graduate its 3 years IM residency, 3 years general cardiology fellowship, then 1-2 year specialty fellowship in Electrophysiology or interventional. The vast majority of neurosurgeons rarely touch a brain. Greenberg is recommended for med students rotating on neurosurgery and for interns/PGY2s staffing the floor. Does anyone have any input on the pros and cons of whether one should take a Neurosurgery or CT surgery job offer for a new grad. The currency for success in surgery is hardwork and We work with neurosurgeons a lot doing craniofacial reconstruction (especially in peds). Content: You can have neuro-trauma, headache, brain bleeds, clots or spinal injury. PAYE would only make sense if you are absolutely certain you are going for PSLF and are going to minimize your low-income years as much as possible (e. Attending wise, Ortho is a huge spectrum ranging from Spine/Trauma to some purely outpatient hand/sports jobs, which can have the potential to rival EM in terms of lifestyle. 5 years to prepare your portfolio. The longer answer is it slightly depends. Neurology involves a one-year internship in internal medicine followed by a three-year neurology residency. They're also very different in the way they're performed, so I guess it's your personal preference of which body system you like the best. I wanted to know what made many of you all to pick cardiology, more specifically interventional cardiology. I eventually decided on Cardiology, for the following reasons: CAD used to be a surgical disease, then it became an interventional disease, and now I think it is becoming a medical disease (CABG has mortality benefit only for LIMA to LAD, PCI has mortality benefit only in STEMI, medical therapy non-inferior in pain control vs May 5, 2023 · Cardiology. Or check it out in the app stores Hospitalist vs Fellowship (Cardiology), help . Meanwhile, Cardiology has advanced to so much that there isn't as much need for surgery anymore. Wouldn’t surprise me if interventional cardiology becomes it’s own fellowship though with all the fancy stuff coming out. Good assessment and advice. This subreddit is a place where high income professionals of all types can ask, answer, discuss, and debate the personal finance and investing questions specific to our unique situations without being criticized, ostracized, or downvoted simply for having a high income and "first world" problems. I've shadowed both and while I find myself drawn to neurosurgery more there are alot benefits to ENT that I like: Neurosurgery - Interesting subject material regarding medical management - Interesting procedures and tech used Welcome to r/neurology home of science-based neurology for physicians, neuroscientists, and fans of neurology. Jul 15, 2023 · Although cardiology seemed like a better lifestyle than cardiac surgery, I definitely have much more passion for cardiac surgery. There is no set “lifestyle”. Private practice is more like 230-300k starting with partners >400k (several docs on r/pathology are making >600k). What is the difference in terms of pay for heme onc academic vs non academic? Like 200-300k vs 600? Curious because I know there are big pay differences in different fields (for instance in anesthesia there is not as large of a gap in pay between private or academic except maybe in some major cities). I don't know what kind of incentives my facility is offering but we are recruiting so hard I imagine that you may be have a lot of negotiation power. Also going through the match a second time for fellowship is not ideal. In cardiology fellowship they have COCATS requirements which are basically the number of procedures of a given type to be qualified to do those. EM is usually one of the better residencies for lifestyle. Neurology hands down. It’s basically a neurologist or radiologist doing a neurosurgical fellowship taught by neurosurgeons to do a fraction of what modern medicine is capable of doing for patients with I planned for neurosurgery throughout almost all of medical school. Bear in mind your SHO years are 2-3 years at best, with applications midway through your last year of training so realistically you only have 1. ER staff arent allowed to "suggest" doctors, tapos hindi naman siya charity so they showed the patient a list. Overall, can be very rewarding as you take care of sick patients and can make a huge impact. Have to be an expert in all of the potential interactions. These are entirely different fields that just happen to deal with the same organ system. I can do things like read my own CTs and MRIs, read eegs and manage AEDs, SAH and place and troubleshoot EVDs. Neurosurgery is not (probably still, wasn't when I applied) as ridiculous because we hand out lots of NTNs to keep the rotas staffed. We already know most things about the heart, but we barely know anything about the brain. Also, interventional neurology is a neurosurgery-driven field always under the department of neurosurgery who also drives the research paving the way. He goes more into the dilemmas faced around invasive treatment vs palliative care, training (particularly the balance between the undeniable need to train junior colleagues vs the increased risk to the patient of allowing a less experienced surgeon do the procedures), the experience of being a neurosurgery patient, the experience of having a The training pathways for cardiology vs. If they work in bangalore, mumbai and delhi to bohot kamayenge but if you take normal 2 tier cities to loss hi hai ek tareeke se as tier 2 mai kaun neurosurgeon ke paas jaayega jabki vo insaan delhi jaakar best neurosurgeon se ilaaj karwa paaye. If I am going to go down a medical speciality it’ll be cardiology, since I can fellowship/ sub specialise in interventional cardiology which really is fascinating. Now is happy attending. patient was on anti platelets post CABG 2 years ago. As such, pay difference in major cities is not significant enough for many people to justify having to take STEMI call, risk MSK injuries, radiation exposure etc. Also, lots of competitive fellowship spots and they match cardiology and gastroenterology very well, which is rare for a community program. Do whatever you like - each of those fields have their plus/minuses. Neuro-intervention (which you can enter via radiology -> interventional -> neuro-int; surgery; neurology) can be a gruelling life. Thoughts on which would be a better choice? Protocol on anti platelets after traumatic SAH- Cardiology vs Neuro battle SIMPLE QUESTION So, we had a patient 60/Male, on floors with mild TBI, gcs 15/15, CT head showing very small subarachnoid hemorrhage after fall from bike. Neurology Cardiology in general is not the most lifestyle friendly sub specialty. Tbh, I am not sure what the question(s) should be really. People often view it that way before they do it because they are used to thinking and managing the structural and coronary pathologies that are seen day in and day out by interventionalists, while they actually have very little exposure to EP principles. Naturally, I want to go into Neurosurgery immediately upon graduation. Heck, neurosurgery now wants to train IRs in neuro-intervention even though it was IR that developed the tools and the technique 😂 oh meron kami story nito. So I can practice “medicine” as well as doing procedures. Another friend matched into peds. Conversely, every call I’ve ever made to anesthesia has been unpleasant and miserable. With CVS Minute Clinic I don't think you'd really get enough experience being a true provider because of the scripts they use. I think the challenging reputation and the ominous vibes/mystery that come with neurosurgery are what initially draws people into the field. Jan 15, 2021 · The short answer is yes you can. SAVE will have somewhat lower payments during residency (depending on salary & tax filing status, but $0 - $150 lower) and prevent interest from accruing over the There is a surplus in major cities, yes. من صغري وانا نفسي ابقا جراح قلب لكني شخص عملي اكتر فكنت عاوز اعرف ليه دايما الناس بتفضل الكارديو عن الct هل لانه بيجيب فلوس اكتر ( معرفش ازاي مع ان… Another vote here for Cardiology, mainly because I'm in Cardiology too, and it's the best decision I ever made. DISCUSSION Yes the Surgery so high up in the C spine sort of feels like it’s practically brain surgery so using a neurosurgeon does seem like it makes more sense, but I’m really wondering whether I’m worrying over nothing because all of these doctors seem extremely well qualified. I basically have three options: - Reject and try cardiology/neurology again with 6 months and not 1 month of study time. Don't get me wrong, I don't think IR is going anywhere. So what’s your thoughts on the matter? Neurosurgery location: LCOL, very familiar area, larger city -salary: 120k but 1099 -- will switch to w2 in near future with large hospital system but pay cut of 10-20k + full benefits Like every other specialty, the biggest variable is academics vs private practice. So… Posted by u/Darkanthos95 - 2 votes and 4 comments Yes, I applied to 37 programs initially and added 8 about a month in (due to the low interviews numbers). The neurosurgery is 4 days per week, no call Pay: 130k midwest I’ve had many pleasant phone calls with surgery, neurosurgery, cards. Now I am totally undecided about what to do and have a few days to decide. Neurosurgery: Youmans and Winn vs Greenberg, Rhoton (neuroanatomy) I came up with a list like this in the past and this is what I have: • Allergy and Immunology Abbas - Basic Immunology Abbas - Cellular and Molecular Immunology Janeway's Immunobiology • Anesthesiology Miller’s Anesthesia • Cardiology Braunwald’s Heart Disease - A Textbook of Cardiovascular Medicine Dubin - Rapid Interpretation of EKGs (Beginner) The Only EKG Book You'll Ever Need Lots of paper work on gen med rotations. Also as a cardiologist I have a much bigger medical repertoire than a neurosurgeon - the analogy I would use is that because of my general cards training I’m both the neurologist AND the neurosurgeon Jan 8, 2018 · Cardiac is hardest: While neurosurgeons might protest, the training for cardiac surgery is much longer. I was IC vs EP in my mind most of first year, decided EP recently. Although cardiology seemed like a better lifestyle than cardiac surgery, I definitely have much more passion for cardiac surgery. Often general critical care doctors don’t know how to manage the more complicated patients and that is why neurosurgery and neurology asked admin to hire a neurointesivist. General cardiology that does imaging will be in very high demand over the next few years due to the takeoff of structural heart disease. Nephrology: Brenner and Rector Neurology: Adams and Victor vs Bradley. Can anyone comment on these NY/NJ programs? Go to school in NY and and came away feeling good after interviewing at these programs. Hey everyone, so I'm a current M2 who's trying to decide between neurosurgery vs ENT. A neurology residency is generally less competitive than a cardiology fellowship. So, there are multiple articles coming out every day about novel therapies— Clinical/Preclinical— which shape the future perspective of our mixed fields in neuroscience. When I consult endocrinology or cardiology or psychiatry- I don’t know their field the way they do. Family Medicine: Rakel GI: Sleisenger and Fordtran Hematology: Immunology: Infectious Disease: Mandell Internal Medicine: Harrison vs Cecil. Both specialties require strong analytical skills, attention to detail, and excellent communication abilities. Cardiology is very variable depending again on the location and size of the practice. I recognize there is a great deal of overlap especially as spinal specialists in each. Dylan, Dylan, Dylan, Dylan, and Dylan I don’t think your question is particularly helpful. the previous that was focused on $$$. After 2 years, didn't like it, switched into neurosurgery. Cardiology residents typically complete a three-year Internal Medicine residency followed by a three-year Cardiology fellowship. Shock in the ICU is basically two things, vasoplegic or hemorrhagic. Based on M2 material, I'm more interested in cardiology than neurology. I am aware of most part of the debate, of the people saying cardiothoracic (ct) surgery is dead and the people saying the future is actually bright and all that. I would definitely not do that, I was more pressured into it and was desperate. My thinking for Radiology route is that 1) I love imaging 2) Residency seems a bit more manageable 3) I can always exit out from operating if I cant handle call to reading films 4) the techniques originated from radiology Nobody should tell you what you have to do, Actually, you should go with the specialty that you like more since both of them will be a different lifestyle, for me, I like to go with interventional cardiology because I like it more since it will include PCI and pacing,and communicating with the patients and their family, rather than just checking on the computer and sitting all day. g. From a medical student perspective, if that is high up on your wish list at this point then don't choose neurosurgery as you will not be happy. However, the opportunities to do certain procedures for IR are a little more vulnerable to local politics and inroads from other specialties. They were shouting at each other and the neurosurgeon started reading the hospital motto on his ID tag to the ortho surgeon i. I worked private practice with a single physician cardiology group (later became two, but all the same), and I had him recommended to me by a previous preceptor, so finding the job and getting in wasn't hard at all. If you don’t like med management you’re going to hate psych. neurosurgery is a very time-demanding and cutthroat field. It sounds like you are drawn to the more 'cerebral', thought-provoking medical fields. Family Medicine: Rakel GI: Sleisenger and Fordtran Hematology: Immunology: Janeway vs Kuby vs Abbas, Middleton (allergy) Infectious Disease: Mandell Internal Medicine: Harrison vs Cecil. I’m a 4th year who also pondered this decision for a long time. Sometimes a little later or earlier depending on the day and how much your attendings feel like torturing you. Agreed IMT is probably less competitive than CST but cardiology (4:1) is not much less competitive vs ENT (5:1). Please review the subreddit rules before posting. You could ask for a referral to a neuro, but in my experience they may give you the runaround. Sometimes, heart and brain surgeries are urgent and you'll need to be on call for both probably. Also higher population of children you'll be operating on as a resident than neurosurgery I'm sure. After 2 years in neurosurgery, he didn't like it either. May 5, 2023 · When choosing between cardiology and neurology, it's essential to consider your personal interests and aptitude. 2nd year fellow headed for Ep. Neurosurgery: Youmans and Winn for reference, Rhoton for neuroanatomy OB/GYN: Williams vs Gabbe. The folks in NS still communicate with patients/families, and have clinic but they absolutely LOVE the OR, willingly fought hard and signed up to a surgeon, and choose to I've worked as a MA in Neurosurgery for the past 4 years and was just accepted to PA school. if you really love endo and minimally invasive work and are optimistic about its future chose IR, you will have the opportunity to treat patients in a number of sub-fields (oncology, liver, ports htn, PE, spine, pain, men, women’s healh, orthoIR, and more). I feel like I have a good grasp on the clinical/outpatient side of things in this field, and know how to perform a reflex/motor exam, evaluate for myelopathic symptoms, etc. This is how you show your competency after fellowship. Hi, everyone. That, and now IRs are wiser about ceding turf because we saw what happened with interventional cardiology. But you were supported in that decision. Most of the applicants I have met have wanted to become neurosurgeons since college/high school. Cardiology vs Cardiac/ICU Anesthesia Hey guys, rising M4 here and stuck between cardio and anesthesia. . 7 years of residency vs 8+). CT Surgery is a pretty well developed field. Apr 13, 2013 · Well, cardiothoracic surgeons and neurosurgeons both work on the most important parts of the body (in my opinion). Cardiac surgery vs interventional cardiology Hey guys, so I've really been trying to figure out what to do with my life and atm it seems to boil down to these 2 medical specialties. Oncology Yeah that meant sometimes you had to wheel someone to CT or push meds or draw labs. I'm a current MS3 about to start clinicals and I had been set on Emergency Medicine forever after working as a tech several years prior to med school. I’d rather focus on a few procedures a day then do 6-12 caths and be on call for STEMIs at all hours for 30 years. However, neurology is also interesting and is a residency option, so taking a neurology elective may be more directly relevant to residency competitiveness if I decide to go that route (whereas cardiology is an IM fellowship option). I don’t care who’s tired or who’s overworked- you are interacting with a fellow colleague and professional so act like it. Teasing out constriction vs restriction, managing advanced chf, bad RV failure all are common scenarios for cardiology. but I wouldn't like to be in the OR all of the time" makes neurosurgery a HARD STOP IMO. If you're with pulm, you'll mostly see COPD. Would rather save $100 but don't want to miss out if the quality is actually that much better! Gi is less emergent relatively and the advanced endoscopy is more about geo spatial orientation vs cardiology is more about radiographic visualisation. Programs can be strong in different ways: clinical experience (service loads, practice settings), subspecialty exposure, inpatient vs outpatient volume, research and academic support, mentorship, board pass rate (cue RITE and eye rolls), geography, culture and happiness of residents (variable over Neurosurgery 100-110 per week. Sports cards Residency wise, Neurosurgery and Ortho are usually 2 of the worst, hours wise. Critical care has to know a bit about everything, since you can become critically ill from failure of any organ system, and you can't just wait around to see what Endo has to say about the myxedema Orthopedic vs Neurosurgeon for Cervical surgery I would like to hear about people's experiences and opinions on which surgical specialty makes more sense. but maybe Today I was a silent observer in a fight between a neurosurgeon and orthopedic surgeon, mostly over OR time and whose emergency was priority. I come with an interesting topic about a futuristic vision of Neurology (specifically interventional) vs Neurosurgery in general. Hated his nsg rotation. Your second sentence: ". Conversely, if you go into surgery and don’t love it, you wont be a happy surgeon. They'll reference it when telling a student or Junior to read up on something. But my goal is cardiology, so FM was not even an option because SOAP would have worked out just due to the sheer number of spots. Plenty of bad calls too, but if I’m calling with some real shit, usually it’s professional. Oct 10, 2021 · From my humble perspective as a cardiac anaesthesiologist who moonlights in neuroanaesthesia, cardiac surgeons are better at managing a a critically ill patient and doing multiple vascular anastomoses quickly. I know graduates that are making >1m but they are q2call and seeing 40 patients a day in clinic. - Accept Gynecology. Temple is a great training but you’re at a major workhorse academic program serving the sickest of the sick - it is absolutely grueling. In general in my experience, employers have recognized that work life balance is a priority for our generation vs. Neurosurgery is a self selecting field over in the US and the match rate is fairly high for applicants. Now ended up as psychiatrist and super happy. Examples of a few gen cardiologists that I know well Private group with 5 cardiologists: Works from 7ish until 6ish most weekdays in hospital and clinic. Seniors and attendings use Youmans. So that being said, is the upgrade from the Classic 3 to the cardiology line that significant? The jump from classic 3 to Cardiology 4 is like 100$ I considered an amplifier but those go for 200$ alone. I am looking on going into cardiology but also open to be a hospitalist. Also cardiology is a longer route than Ortho as well, not even including advanced fellowships TLDR: Cardiology is a great, cognitively gratifying field with many options and practice options with hours similar to ortho. I wonder what are my chances of matching into a good program in the NY area? I have the same level of interest in surgery and cardiology. You knew when it was you vs a patient even if that patient had the last name al Saud or you vs an attending even if that attending was a member of the National Academy of Sciences, it was your word first. But yes 3/45 interviews. Bailey. e. I don’t know about EP being more “cerebral” and “intellectual”. Surgery vs IM because you want to do something with the heart is not the best way to think about things. integrity, quality. Jul 4, 2017 · Neurosurgery you can operate on people who are essentially dead and have horrible outcomes. Cardiothoracic you get the patients that cardiology couldn't fixin other words, the sickest patients who also don't have good outcomes. It depends heavily on the job (location, type of practice, how aggressive they are about income vs lifestyle). so once there was this patient in the ER, tapos kailangan ng cardio surgeon. If you enjoy managing vascular disease and also enjoy surgical techniques then chose VS. I totally changed to medicine and now I’m in GI, was an excellent change for me. For those I know in neurosurgery, quality of life was not in the top 20 reasons they chose their field. I don't have as much experience with neurosurgery, but I would imagine this swings in the other direction as most people probably wouldn't go for an elective craniotomy, and I think the majority of their business is older, but I'm not an expert. Mar 6, 2018 · As someone who is going to be an IC, my perspective is that both are cool, both are life saving fields, but neither is superior. From my humble perspective as a cardiac anaesthesiologist who moonlights in neuroanaesthesia, cardiac surgeons are better at managing a a critically ill patient and doing multiple vascular anastomoses quickly. Salaries are okay 350k can be achieve outside academia, 900k you need to be working more than a neurosurgeon in residency academia salaries sucks -dad a south neurologist, I asked him # CT Surgeons: 2008: 4,837 2011: 4,681 2016: 4,483 2021: 4,473 CT surgery is the only specialty I found that has such a steep decline in total of practicing physicians. Some disorders respond to things much more effectively, borderline - DBT, PTSD - CPT I would argue that this is true of every specialty. Neurosurgery you save a lot of lives, but also work with patients that are completely neurologically devastated. I went into interventional cardiology because when I was making this same decision, I was more comfortable doing the boring every-day things of internal medicine than of surgery, and the interventional cardiology path just worked out. Both have an intricate understanding of pathophysiology and are well placed to decide whether the patient should go for medication, intervention or surgery. Did neurosurgery research, shadowed derm and plastics, did electives in vascular surgery, ENT, pathology. Its like "should I do neurology or neurosurgery" threads. Really value work life balance and resident happiness. uztlggd izcwek jloz rjmbg nhuqrdi ndfm qeqsd tsqbd pgrv hfomqa