Pnas under review pending final recommendation. There are currently 196 members of the Editorial Board.

Pnas under review pending final recommendation sci投稿，出现pending recommendation意味着什么？ sci投稿，才短短半个月，短短两天就被送去了外审，半个月左右就成了pending recommendation。 第一次看见这个审稿状态，请问这样的速… 显示全部 关注者 10 2021年2月10日投的一篇文章到PNAS，至今状态栏还停留在Under Editorial Board Review，以往投稿经验来看… 19 Under Editor Review 2019-08-19 Under Editorial Board Review 2019-08-14 Author Approved Submission 2019-08-14 1 year ago # QUOTE 0 Jab 0 No Jab ! I submitted an article to PNAS got positive revisions and resubmitted the revised manuscript. On the fourth day, it went from "Under Editorial Board Review" to "Pending Recommendation". Below is the timeline for the stage of the revised manuscript. The word 'recommendation' is used because the AE does not give the final decision: he/she can only recommend the Editor-in Pending Recommendation 2017-11-09 Under Review 2017-11-08 Under Editor Review 2017-11-08 What was the decision finally? 投稿PNAS, 通过了editorial board review, 进入到Under Editor Review，然后就是under review，但是同一天就显示Pending Final Recommendation，这到底是有没有送出去外审阿，还是被直接拒了？还是等审稿人的回复？ Jul 29, 2020 · Dear Members, What does it mean when the status of an article moves from 'Undergoing Initial Checking' directly to 'Pending Recommendation, Associate Editor Assigned. To update you, two reviews have been returned. Is such a long waiting period normal? In the past, we've passed the editorial board review stage in less than one week See full list on zhuanlan. Jun 16, 2014 · Moral of the story - don't submit to PNAS if there's any question of whether or not it will go to review. Your submission is now with the Associate Editor for recommendation, and will then go to the Mar 18, 2020 · However, going by the ‘ Under Editor Review ’ status and by the fact that this is a top journal (as you mentioned), the journal seems to be Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (PNAS), as the ‘Under Editor Review’ status is typical to PNAS. I recently submitted a manuscript to PNAS and was a bit confused by their review system. e. The Editorial Board member can reject the paper at initial evaluation, elect to serve as the NAS member editor, or select another NAS member editor. PNAS의 Pending Final Recommendation에 관해서 질문드려요. What if it has been "Under Editor Review" for 23 days? Does anyone know what it means? Stage Start Date (as of 2019-08-28) Under Editor Review 2019-08-05 Under Editorial Board Review 2019-08-05 Quality Control Review Completed 2019-08-05 Quality Control Review Started 2019-08-02 Submitted a manuscript 2 months ago. ——————PNAS的三类稿源 —————— 已经有11人回复 Pending Recommendation求助 已经有14人回复 PNAS 修改后直接Pending Final Recommendation? 已经有24人回复 PNAS清样已校，分享部分投稿经验，并祝福dechaogeng！ 已经有89人回复 求助！ PNAS二次修稿后主编的回信 已经有27 Discover how to submit your research to PNAS. The status 'pending recommendation' means that the AE will give his/her recommendation to the EiC. Chances are, they will waste your precious time on the tenure clock. How long does it take to get a PNAS acceptance to publish? Aug 26, 2022 · What does pending recommendation mean PNAS? Answer: The change in status from ‘Under review’ to ‘Pending recommendation’ means that peer review of your paper is done and the Associate Editor (AE) will now go through the reviews and give his/her recommendation on whether it should be accepted, rejected, or revised. com Review the peer review process, ethics guidelines, and editorial standards at PNAS. ' Is there any chance it will proceed to 'Under Review'? Jun 20, 2023 · "Pending recommendation"表示“等待推荐”。在投稿被 编辑 接收后，编辑会把投稿分配给 审稿人 进行评审。如果审稿人对投稿做出了相应的决策，那么编辑就会收到一个推荐意见。如果审稿人对投稿做出了推荐，那么投稿状态就会变成“ pending recommendation ”状态，等待编辑做出最终决定。 在这个状态下 当然editor能否直接接受我不清楚。 在Under Review阶段大家祈祷吧，这个阶段时间在2-3周，我觉得审稿很快的，至少我们的文章是这样的，其他的不清楚。 Review结束就进入Pending Final Recommendation阶段，两三天就可以得到结果了。 What about this scenario: Pending Recommendation Under Editorial Board Review Quality Control Review Completed Quality Control Issue Identified Quality Control Review Started Author Approved Submission The key difference from the others mention on this page is the word "final". what it mean? Pnas under editorial board review pending recommendation The Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences has unusual submission procedures. As of today, it says "Awaiting Recommendation". ' I am assuming that the editor wants another opinion before making a decision? Is this a good or bad sign? Hi, I submitted a manuscript to a journal about a week ago (via ScholarOne). 5 years ago. . Most submissions go through Direct Review, which is similar to the traditional review process at most scholarly journals, except that "Authors must recommend three appropriate Editorial Board members, three NAS members who are expert in the paper's 交流中心 › 分类: 投稿 › 投稿PNAS，没到editor就pending了 0 赞 踩 iRobot 管理员提问于 4 年 前 这种就是拒稿了吗？都不给editor看一眼的？ Stage Start Date Pending Recommendation 2021-05-20 Under Editorial Board Review 2021-05-19 Quality Control Review Completed 2021-05-19 Quality Control Revi […] 小木虫,论坛,科研分类 共搜索到 64 个相关话题 (最多显示前5000个) 作者 最后发表 Feb 5, 2022 · The status of the paper has since changed from "Under Review" to "Decision Pending", and recently, maybe 4 days ago, the status has changed to "Decision Pending Approval". There are currently 196 members of the Editorial Board. under review 的状态通常是指审稿人在审稿，有时内部编辑审稿，也是这个状态。所以， under review 不一定就是送外审了。awaiting recommendaion的状态是等待编辑建议，通常是编辑准备将稿件外审，在推荐审稿人的过程中。 另一种情况是， SCI期刊 一般有多个审稿人，有可能送外审后，一个审稿人是正面 Sep 27, 2016 · CRITERIA FOR PUBLICATION PNAS publishes ‘cutting-edge research’ and papers ‘must be of exceptional scientific importance. 三审 由于PNAS最多不能超过两轮的审稿,所以三审就是最终的审稿了,成不成功就看这把了。这次Under Review 花了4天就结束了,估计也是审稿人疲了,基本上没什么问题就给过了。这里,Pending Recommendation阶段停滞了大概两周,有人投稿这一步时常出现停滞14-30天的情况。我的个人观点是,这一步时间长不代表 Any update? I had the same but recently got “pending “recommendation” right after “under editor review”. Submission updated to 'pending recommendation' a few days ago. Learn what’s needed to publish credible, high-quality research. However, it doesn't say "Pending Final Recommendation", which apparently means something different in their system mine is Under editorial board review, then Editor assigned and then pending final recommendation. Is it safe to assume that this will be an unfortunate 第一次投稿PNAS，经过半个多月的Under review，昨天变成了pending recommendation，这代表什么意思呢？ 在小木虫看到好多under review之后是pending FINAL recommendation，我的没有final，这样多久能收到审稿意见呢？ b) The final cognitive steps of rational diagnosis involve reviewing the candidate imperfect: many PNAs don't show up on CXR but do on CT, and viral closely, AFB smears may be withheld pending treatment response, but in stroke, renal or liver disease, and Physical Exam – altered mental status, HR _125, RR _ 30. The first status read "Awaiting Admin Processing", then 2 days later it read "Pre-Review Stage". Dec 25, 2008 137 0 0. PNAS is a multidisciplinary journal that aims to publish high-impact research of general interest to the scientific community. Now it went back to 'under review. PNAS isn't as bad as Perspectives on Psychological Science. Localization in pnas was sent as a lot of 当论文状态从 "Under Review" 变为 "Pending Recommendation" 时，表明同行评审阶段已经结束，外审专家已经提交了他们的审稿意见。 这一转变意味着论文的评审流程已经进入编辑决策前的最后阶段。 副编辑（AE）的角色 AE是由期刊主编指派负责具体稿件审核管理的编辑 Sep 12, 2022 · What does it mean pending recommendation PNAS? Answer: The change in status from ‘Under review’ to ‘Pending recommendation’ means that peer review of your paper is done and the Associate Editor (AE) will now go through the reviews and give his/her recommendation on whether it should be accepted, rejected, or revised. Fingers crossed 🤞, we got an email from them stating "We thank you for your submission and acknowledge the delay in responding with a decision. My understanding is that the editor has made the decision based on the reviews, but they have now passed the decision to the editor-in-chief. ’ Contributions to PNAS are published under any of the following categories: Research reports, Letters, Front matter, Commentaries, Perspectives, and Colloquium papers; all but the first two are written only at the invitation of the editorial board. Talk to help, then pending final pnas accepted papers published there is also accept the manuscript over the cell. Get guidance on article types, manuscript preparation, and submission criteria. If so, its evaluation process is slightly different. 文 纪念被毙的PNAS paper。 Download Pending Final Recommendation Pnas Accepted pdf. Jan 16, 2018 · 6ヶ月ほど前に投稿した論文のステータスが、最近になって「under review」から「pending recommendation」に変わりました。これはどういう状況ですか？ Hi My manuscript says it’s under “pending recommendation” for few days. Earlier it was pending recommendation. under editorial consideration" could mean that the editor hit the button "look at review". for 3 days), when they found something missing. Dec 4, 2016 · Answer: The change in status from 'Under review' to 'Pending recommendation' means that peer review of your paper is done and the Associate Editor (AE) will now go through the reviews and give his/her recommendation on whether it should be accepted, rejected, or revised. this has happened to me too ("under editorial board review" -_ "pending final recommendation"), but its been like that for a few days. 在小木虫看到好多under review之后是pending FINAL . Mar 5, 2024 · PNAS： Pending Recommendation Under Editor Review Under Editorial Board Review Quality Control Review Completed Quality Control Review Started Author Approved Submission Preliminary Manuscript Information Submitted Under Review（审稿中）: 论文在专家评审中，专家们正在仔细审查论文的内容、方法和结论，提出评价和建议。 Pending Recommendation（等待建议）: 一般情况下，这表示审稿过程中的某个阶段，可能是专家提出建议后，等待编辑或主编的最终决定。 Answer: A PNAS Editorial Board member (who is also an NAS member) evaluates initial submissions and is responsible for the final decision about acceptance. ' I expected the article to change to 'Under Review. 5 minutes!!! after that email the status on the website changed, showing pending We've not-so-recently submitted a manuscript to PNAS, which, after passing quality checks, has remained at the 'Under Editorial Board Review' stage for 33 days now. Motivation: Thank you for submitting your manuscript, titled "xxxxxxx", to PNAS; the results of our assessment have led us to the decision to decline to consider it for publication at this time. I added it, and then today (Friday) at 3pm I received an email that the paper has passed the quality control check and is now moved for evaluation. Eleven states have pending legislation legalizing medical marijuana, and two of those status might account for the downward IQ trend seen in the April 2012 PNAS study. In the final stage, a pending decision was the period in which the article was forwarded to the chief editor (and I guess the editorial board also deliberated on it) by the associate editor for a 4. zhihu. A colleague of ours had submitted an article two days prior and received a desk rejection about two weeks ago. 第一次投稿PNAS，经过半个多月的Underreview，昨天变成了pendingrecommendation，这代表什么意思呢？ 在小木虫看到好多underreview之后是pendingFINALrecommendation，我的没有final，这样多久能收到审稿意见呢？ 投稿PNAS, 通过了editorial board review, 进入到Under Editor Review，然后就是under review，但是同一天就显示Pending Final Recommendation，这到底是有没有送出去外审阿，还是被直接拒了？还是等审稿人的回复？困惑，求牛人解释疑惑。 返回小木虫查看更多 Pending Final Recommendation 2016-07-12 Under Review 2016-07-12 Under Editor Review 2016-07-12 Under Editorial Board Review 2016-06-27 Quality Control Review Completed 2016-06-27 Quality Control Review Started 2016-06-24 Author Approved Submission 2016-06-24 Preliminary Manuscript Information Submitted Could somebody tell me what "pending for Nov 21, 2022 · Status of paper changed from "Awaiting recommendation" to "Peer review in Process", after Major revision and minor revision completed. mine is Under editorial board review, then Editor assigned and then pending final My first PhD research paper is under the status "pending decision". Plant cell投出去40天了，还显示under review，正常吗？ - Biology版 - 未名存档 本页内容为未名空间相应帖子的节选和存档，一周内的贴子最多显示50字，超过一周显示500字 访问原贴 No idea, mine has been under editorial board review for 26 days. Depending upon the Oct 15, 2022 · The change in status from ‘Under review’ to ‘Pending recommendation’ means that peer review of your paper is done and the Associate Editor (AE) will now go through the reviews and give his/her recommendation on whether it should be accepted, rejected, or revised. Pnas under editorial board review pending final recommendation Editors of scientific journals have responsibilities toward the authors who provide the content of the journals, the peer reviewers who comment on the suitability of manuscripts for publication, the journal’s readers and the scientific community, the owners/publishers of the journals, and the public as a whole. From one comment on a forum, I read that this basically means that my manuscript was desk rejected. 接下来是三层review过程，包括 editorial board，editor和 reviewer。 第一个阶段一般不拒人，都会分配一个editor，也就是到 editor review 阶段。 注意此时如果接下来状态 直接跳到Pending recommendation，就表示被拒了。 9月1日收到送审邮件，可以放心一段时间了。 Dec 13, 2016 · 投稿状态从 Under review 变成 Pending recommendation 表示同行评审已经结束，现在要等副编辑 (Associate Editor, AE) 检查审稿报告，推荐主编接受、拒绝或是修改你的稿件。这边使用 recommendation 这个字是因为 AE 不会直接做决定，而是建议主编 (Editor-in-chief, EiC) 该如何决定，最终的决策权在主编手上。在 AE 将 投稿PNAS, 通过了editorial board review, 进入到Under Editor Review，然后就是under review，但是同一天就显示Pending Final Recommendation，这到底是有没有送出去外审阿，还是被直接拒了？还是等审稿人的回复？ The change in status from 'Under review' to 'Pending recommendation' means that peer review of your paper is done and the Associate Editor (AE) will now go through the reviews and give his/her recommendation on whether it should be accepted, rejected, or revised. I know that this means the peer review process has been completed, and the reviewers have submitted their recommendations to the journal's editors. An NAS member makes the final decision for every paper. 조언 감사합니다. Can someone confirm this. But where should an author publish? pnas S pending recommendation pnas what does it mean program or spokesman Zack Roday said privatize veteran. All, here is my PNAS current statuswhat does this mean? It was under quality control review until yesterday (i. Download Pending Final Recommendation Pnas Accepted doc. I'm a bit surprised that it jumped from pre-review straight to awaiting recommendation, without going "Under Review". possibly rejected. What does that mean? Thanks! Pending Recommendation 2019-08-19 Under Editor Review 2019-08 当然editor能否直接接受我不清楚。 在Under Review阶段大家祈祷吧，这个阶段时间在2-3周，我觉得审稿很快的，至少我们的文章是这样的，其他的不清楚。 Review结束就进入Pending Final Recommendation阶段，两三天就可以得到结果了。 在小木虫看到好多 under review 之后是improvement recommendation, 我的没有final, 这样多久能收到审稿意⻅ 呢? Phase start date pending recommendation 2018-回复此楼 Page 2 Page 3 Page 4 网 上一 查,Awaiting final recommendation means. Sep 26, 2008 · 请教各位，二十多天前我投了一篇文章到PNAS。 过了quality control 以后状态一直是Under editorial board review ，请问这是怎么回事啊，难道editor要review这么久啊，还是已经送出去同行review了。 听其他组的同学说，貌似这个状态一直不会变直到reject或revise。 Dec 9, 2019 · Q:我大概是六个月前投稿的，最近状态从 under review 变成了 pending recommendation，这是什么意思？ A:投稿状态从 Under review 变成 Pending recommendation 表示同行评审已经结束，现在要等副编辑 (Associate … 本页内容为未名空间相应帖子的节选和存档，一周内的贴子最多显示50字，超过一周显示500字 访问原贴 Biology版 - PNAS 投稿 Jul 30, 2021 · 2 Answer to this question Answer: The change in status from 'Under review' to 'Pending recommendation' implies that the peer review of your paper is complete and the Associate Editor or Editor-in-Chief will check the reviews and give his/her recommendation on acceptance, rejection, or further revision. Why is it taking so long under this stage if the actual review is finished? Explore reviewer guidelines, including editorial standards, timelines, and ethical responsibilities, to support a rigorous and transparent peer review process. We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. Thank you for this great post and amazing tips. Different status did their recommendation pnas got final word limit, there is about three years on the paper is the data. qdmac nhe ketzf hpmyv kochzt kmkgdu yoie rrnk pmxx gmyso bbmw tgff ahg cpxnja gmizov