Atc vs grigri A GriGri makes a ground fall after a normal fall almost impossible, assuming you're high enough up. Learn the difference between the Grigri and the Grigri+. I've been eyeing a grigri recently as holding tight on the ATC for braking when my lead partners are taking rest starts to wear on my hands during the 3 hour sessions. comObviously, you will need the ideal backpack. I got it to have an assistant braking device for outdoor lead climbing. Master the pros and cons of ATC, GriGri, and passive assist systems to become a more reliable climbing partner. Beal Birdie vs Petzl GriGri- which is better? The Beal Birdie is superior to the Petzl GriGri because of its all-steel construction and lower price point. Nov 26, 2013 · Find rock climbing routes, photos, and guides for every state, along with experiences and advice from fellow climbers. This year, due to wear, I replaced my rappel rope with a 9mm canyoneering static line Feb 19, 2025 · Is the Petzl Neox the next must-have belay device? We review its smooth operation, pros, and cons for sport and trad climbers. However, it is important to note that this method of lowering a climber is strictly forbidden according to the manual. The argument that GriGri's "promote sloppy techniques" is just silly. Note: especially for crevasse rescue, it’s really important to practice these different ratchet systems in the real world. It automatically catches in under 1m of rope generally. Apr 27, 2021 · The GriGri and ATC (either the ATC-XP or the original ATC) are the belay devices we see most often at the gym. Do you use a GriGri or ATC for Rappel? and why? I've heard people saying grigri are not good for rap but I see a lot of people still use it. The Birdie is a little bit heavier- but should last a lot longer because of the all-steel construction. Been using an 11mm static line with an original GriGri. Black Diamond’s ATC-XP adheres to the age-old adage: If it ain't broke, don't fix it. I was wondering if it is better to learn lead belay on an ATC and later transition to a grigri or just go strait to belaying with a grigri? I will be learning in a gym with no intent to climb multi pitch outdoor or anything yet. I own an ATC-XP, ATC-Guide, springless Sticht plate, GriGri, CT-Alpine Up, a chain link and various homemade belay devices. If you've always used a GriGri but are open to trying something lighter and less expensive, the Smart also fills that bill. com Jan 3, 2024 · GriGri vs ATC: The Pros & Cons The GriGri and the ATC climbing device have the same aim: to keep the climber safe. Dec 22, 2022 · Discover the side-by-side comparison of the GriGri vs ATC belaying devices: history, pros and cons, best use. Plus belaying a second through them is much easier IMO. Don't listen to any of these gumbies talking about how the grigri is better. It feeds slack with ease, securely catches lead falls, and securely auto-blocks when belaying a follower from above on multi-pitch routes. LIVE AN UNUSUAL AND EXCITING LIFE!!•••Unboxing the new Petzl NEOX and comparing it to the GRIGRI and GRIGRI +•••Help us inspire more people by sharing this v Nov 6, 2017 · Kyle, there are a huge number of pro/anti, grigri vs. The device can be used with a wide range of rope diameters, from 8. All you need to get mult-pitching! Used an ATC for many years, then switched to the ATC Pilot a few years ago for gym/sport climbing and I really like it. Geometry assisted devices depend on the brake side being in a low position and have minimal tension in order to lock, so if you don't hold the rope at it runs parallel to the climbers side, the device will not lock. Perfect for single-pitch climbs. Why? Please see the below section re: panicking. IMO, the safety features of the GriGri make it always worth using over and ATC if the use case allows it. I'm an ATC user by choice, I do use a grigri, but I'm not comfortable doing so to belay folks. Petzl GriGri Advantages: Assisted Braking: The GriGri has an Dec 13, 2023 · The ATC takes a secondary set of skills to lower someone [while belaying] from a long distance from above. Here, we review and recommend the best assisted-braking belay devices for rock climbing. a tube style device for outdoor rock climbing. Background: When Petzl released the GriGri + in 2017, it featured a superior camming unit compared to the GriGri 2. That being said, the Birdie is cheaper and performed really well. There isn't anything on the market that remotely comes close to the ease of use for lead belay. seminar where the main instructor indicated that he is comfortable using the ATC in guide-mode without always having a hand on the brake-side of the rope because when used that way, it is an "auto-locking device. But after googling and reading up on grigri's I just feel more confused than informed on what Jun 23, 2017 · A review of two different belay devices: the Mammut Smart and the Petzl Gri Gri + from The Climbing Zine, June 2017, field tested. 0 – with brake assist Black Diamond ATC Pilot – with brake assist DMM Grip – 7 Years and It Still Never Officially Came Out Edelrid Jul² – with brake assist Trango Vergo – mechanical Jun 13, 2018 · Interested in the Petzl Grigri + belay device? Our in-depth review breaks down the pros and cons and compares it to the GriGri 2. Even if you primarily rely on an assisted braking device like the Grigri above when belaying, it's important to have a backup—and I recently started using a Mammut Smart 2. Jul 23, 2025 · Explore top rappel devices like the ATC, Figure 8, and Grigri. Is there any benefit to using a figure 8 as opposed to tubular belay devices or a locking assist belay device? Thanks Yann does some incredible stuff. A rundown of the most common belay devices, and the pros and cons of each. Moved PermanentlyThe document has moved here. Jan 4, 2024 · GriGri vs GriGri+ vs GriGri 2 See the 40+ brands who make Belay Devices Belay Device Reviews & Overviews DMM Pivot – guide mode dream Mammut Smart 2. Designed for all climbers and suitable for learning belayers, the Petzl GRIGRI + belay device offers assisted braking with an anti-panic handle and a special mode for comfortable top-rope belays. After using the ATC for so long, the muscle memory is the same for the Pilot, and I didn't have to relearn belaying like with a GriGri. It works by generating a pinching force from the force imparted to the device's live end. But that problem exists just as much, if not moreso, in an ATC. It is particularly well-suited for traditional climbing, multi-pitch climbing, and mountaineering, where adaptability and lightweight gear are paramount. The number one rule of belaying is pay attention to your climber, so many feel the ATC Aug 15, 2025 · Master abseiling with our Descender Device Showdown: Figure 8 vs ATC vs GriGri. However, their mechanisms and features vary from one another, while some climbers prefer the GriGri and others the ATC. Sep 7, 2020 · The Grigri is a single rope, assisted braking belay device from climbing gear manufacturers Petzl. I climb a lot with people who are already experienced with regular grigri. If the belayer panics and does not grip the brake strand, the device won’t lock, climber goes splat. 6K Dislike Nov 18, 2019 · Coming from using an ATC which we both feel is more intuitive, we were more interested in testing the Mega Jul, Smart and Pilot. However, after a few falls I became more anxious and no longer wanted my belayer to use an unassisted belay device in case he/she fainted, got hit by something or similar. 5mm Want to learn more about Adventure and Experiential Education? Then this podcast is for you! Listeners of this podcast will get; - Adventure Programming Theory - Facilitation Tips - Activity Ideas - Industry Career Advice - Interviews from Industry Professionals High 5 Adventure Learning Center is a non-profit educational organization dedicated to helping individuals, teams, schools Black diamond atc pilot vs grigri xp belay device guide bd petzl reverso outdoor gear video alpine sport using - expocafeperu. May 13, 2025 · This Petzl GriGri review is for all the climbers around the world looking for an assisted braking belay device and have not yet tried the GriGri. The two devices are remarkably similar, though each has distinct differences. Use this article to help decide which belay device to buy! My ATC has gotten about 5 years of good use and is starting seem like it might be time put it away except for some rappelling. Jul 11, 2025 · We test climbing belay devices for all types of climbing. " Dec 15, 2021 · Exactly how to belay from above with a grigri, atc, mega jul, cordelette anchors and more. ATC guide is pretty much the gold standard belay device for mountaineering. Petzl USA. Nov 22, 2023 · Find rock climbing routes, photos, and guides for every state, along with experiences and advice from fellow climbers. How does it stack up to the Grigri? We put it to the test. To follow: broken legs; ambulance; guilt; disrupted friendships; etc. What are some of the issues, pros, and cons of the different methods of locking a figure 8 or ATC while on a free hanging rappel? I know the most common way to lock an 8 is to simply cross the brake line over in a half lock. Oct 1, 2021 · ATC vs GriGri Mechanical devices likes the GriGri and Birdie offer a braking system that can hold a rope in a locked position if the belayer were to let go of the rope. Yes. This function distinguishes it from traditional belay devices such as a Sticht plate or an ATC, whose braking mechanisms depend entirely on the user What is the Best ATC Belaying Device in 2024? Here's a list of the Top 9 ATC devices for belaying based on our experiences and expertise. The GriGri + (Plus) The new GriGri Plus comes with great upgrades, such as; two belay settings for top-rope and lead belaying, anti-panic mode and smoother rope management for both belaying and descending. 11+ confidently in a gym setting. My favorite belay device I've ever used was an old sticht plate. Find out how to pick the right one, use it safely, and keep it in top condition for your climbing trips. Gallery Of Grigri Vs Atc Leave Your Reply on Grigri Vs Atc Click here to cancel reply. And that any climber would prefer a competent belayer rather than a fancy belay device. GriGri: Which to Choose and Why There’s no doubt you’ve heard many debacles over belay devices between climbers. In that setting, the only benefit of an ATC is that it is cheaper. Search "belay device" @TheRockClubNY ATC or Grigri? #climbing #belaying 3. However, I've noticed that some climbers prefer using ATCs or Mammut devices, arguing they're safer and less prone to mechanical failure. Caving, mountaineering, multi-pitch, cragging, canyoning, each activity has its device. Aug 14, 2018 · Find rock climbing routes, photos, and guides for every state, along with experiences and advice from fellow climbers. Petzl offers a wide selection of descenders and innovative belay devices designed for all vertical activities. If you're partial to tube-style devices but want some extra holding power and security, then the Smart 2. Sep 21, 2023 · The GriGri and its various iterations have dominated the belay device market for thirty years, while tube-style options like the ATC Guide and DMM Pivot continue to hold strong. 攀岩確保器的種類與原理 攀岩確保器主要分為以下三種類型： 1. . If you want the best active assisted-braking device on the market, the Petzl GriGri is a perennial favorite, and the GriGri+ is best for beginners. ATC, lequel est le meilleur ? Vous obtiendrez des réponses différentes à cette question en fonction de la personne à laquelle vous vous adressez. ” Both devices are capable of accommodating high-risk situations, but the GriGri is more likely to switch between uses at a faster rate, which can be essential in extreme or life-or-death situations. Jan 3, 2024 · GriGri vs ATC Belay Device: What’s The Difference? What is an ATC? The ATC climbing device, which stands for Air Traffic Control, is a tube-style belay device, usually with two holes and a plastic-wrapped loop of braided wire connected to the underside. The ATC-Pilot is hands-down the best belay device I've ever used. Jul 15, 2010 · When I belay I usually use a grigri but I also have an ATC. Love his work, a modified version of that technique almost gaurentees the grigri to catch, just run the cache loop between your legs having the MT on the back of your harness (gear loop) The friction between the grigri and your inner thigh or crotch is enough to act as a break hand. Dec 5, 2024 · The Petzl GriGri is an active assisted-braking device that performs well in every belaying and lowering task, earning our highest honor as the best belay device on the market. Hey everyone, I've been climbing for about 7 months, so if I don't say something correctly I'm sorry! Recently within the past two months I have gotten into top rope climbing and I can confidently climbing 5. It should be said that both the ATC and the GriGri can be used in sport, top rope, and Jun 27, 2023 · The one downside to an ATC versus a Gri-Gri is that an inattentive belayer using an ATC can easily drop their climber to the ground. Would you feel comfortable having someone belay you with an ATC or Mammut if you're used to the GriGri? Dec 1, 2023 · Petzl GriGri – #1 Most Owned Mechanical Device We talked at length in our post on the most owned and wanted tube style belay devices about how Black Diamond has cemented the word ATC into the climbing zeitgeist to mean any tube style belay device, and it’s not uncommon to hear climbers referring to mechanical belay devices as a GriGri. Grigri vs atc safety reddit pilot mens watch with compass suunto core gps black diamond nixon outdoor gear - expocafeperu. Oct 9, 2023 · This is closer to the Grigri-style of lowering a climber. Jun 16, 2018 · Conclusion From my testing, the Mammut Smart 2. Geometry ones are Jul, Smart, ATC pilot, Click Up etc. It's an ideal device for belaying both leaders and top-ropers, either sport or Apr 16, 2022 · Find rock climbing routes, photos, and guides for every state, along with experiences and advice from fellow climbers. (At least in my Experience enhanced security with the ATC-Pilot Belay Device. End of story. May 18, 2025 · The Petzl Neox is a surprisingly good new device for lead belaying single pitch routes. Jun 13, 2017 · What is the the newest GriGri difference? Petzl’s newest GriGri takes the body of the GriGri 2 and adds an updated cam (the same cam as the GriGri +). It Jul 29, 2024 · Petzl's new Neox is a sleek assisted-braking belay device. Instead, be resourceful with the gear you probably already have. I will sometimes be climbing with less experienced people. The Petzl Neox is the best for belaying a leader, and the Black Diamond ATC Guide is out favorite tube-style device with auto-locking capabilities. (price does not matter in this discussion) I'm mainly concerned about the cam engaging too often when lowering or due to rope drag which could get frustrating. After reading this article, you will know the difference between GriGri vs ATC. So I have always used a regular atc for belay a lead climber, trad mostly but that really doesn't matter. ATC on multipitch trad climbing I’ve seen both, and used both. Belaying with a Grigri vs. Confidently choose the right belay device. You outdoor gear needs to be stored in a bag, and you will need to ensure that the pack you use is comfortable and this means that this is one of the most important items for you to have on your hiking or camping trips. Oct 4, 2018 · I’ve been rappelling out of my tree for years. Aug 22, 2023 · ATC Vs. My rappel rope is my tether at hunting height and my GriGri is on from the get go. Mar 17, 2022 · The basics behind the Petzl GriGri, one of climbing’s most popular belay devices. Aug 3, 2023 · The Grigri is also preferred for intensive top-rope sessions or for climbers needing hands-free capabilities. The Birdie seemed to be very similar to the classic auto-locking Gri-Gri which has been around for 30 years without much competition. That could be because of a simple mistake – like a newer belayer mishandling the rope, a large fall, and a loose belay with a lot of slack causing a rope burn. Dec 13, 2018 · Find rock climbing routes, photos, and guides for every state, along with experiences and advice from fellow climbers. All you need is a friction hitch, long sling, and a modern belay device like a Grigri or “guide-mode” style belay device. The grigri is over hyped. I like to think I'm skilled with all of them. It is also the recommended lowering method of the Black Diamond ATC Pilot. Harkening back to the time-tested tube-style belay devices of old, the ATC-XP is a cheap and simple but entirely functional device for new and experienced climbers alike. Tube | Courses and Guided Experiences: alpineinstitute. ATC ATC（Air Traffic Controller）確保器是一種摩擦式確保器，其原理是利用繩索與確保器之間的摩擦力，在攀岩者墜落時產生制動效果。 ATC使用簡便，價格實惠，是新手攀岩者的首選。 2. GriGri, specifically for top-belay I recently attended a two day trad. 11-5. Is an ATC better than a Grigri? We break down the differences between the types of belay devices and share our favorites for different types of climbing. comoriginal sound - American Alpine Institute. Devices like the Grigri are referred to as “Assisted Braking Devices”, meaning that the device will assist you in locking the rope when your climber takes a fall. If you are not sure which one is best for you, here are some pros and cons of both belaying devices. Oct 24, 2023 · Mountain Standards Gear Review: IFMGA/AMGA Mountain Guide Mike Lewis announces that the Trango Vergo has replaced the Petzl Grigri in his kit, awarding the Trango Vergo five stars. But I usually rappel on 11 mm BlueWater II static rope, and such a large tough rope can jamb if this lock method is used while the device is weighted. Jul 29, 2019 · If you’re going more than one pitch off the deck a plaquette device like the Black Diamond ATC Guide or Petzl Reverso 4 is an easy pick. Choose your climbing companion! Nov 3, 2020 · More advanced Grigri users may find the anti-panic handle unnecessary and hindering to the lowering experience. The Dec 5, 2024 · The Edelrid Mega Jul is what you're looking for. Dec 22, 2022 · Grigri vs. The Pilot is simple, light, and perfect for what it does. GriGri vs "normal" ATCs I've recently taken a tentative step out of bouldering and into "real climbing" I did the top rope thing for a while and found it tedious, after asking around for advice on sport climbing, i received mixed messages about which ATC to use, what do you think r/climbing ? In this video, I break down the key differences between the ATC and the GRIGRI, including safety features, compatibility, use cases, and more! Whether you’re brand new to climbing or just want a Lead Climbing: ATC vs GriGri vs etc. My channel/content is Is an ATC better than a Grigri? We break down the differences between the types of belay devices and share our favorites for different types of climbing. Cam assisted ones are Grigri, Birdie, kinetic etc. While old-school devices such as the figure eight and ATC still have their place in the climbing world, the I've mainly used GriGri devices for belaying, as that's what my gym provides. Feb 3, 2019 · Garda hitch prusik plaquette style belay device (like a Black Diamond ATC Guide or Petzl Reverso) Grigri Petzl Traxion Let’s have a look at the pros and cons of these. It does not represent TikTok’s views or advice. Im thinking about using a grigri instead. Mammut Aline Smart Details The Mammut Alpine Smart has been often Dec 5, 2024 · The Petzl GriGri+ is the best active assisted-braking belay device for newer climbers and feels very familiar to anybody who has used a GriGri before. I like my GriGri for more casual climbing, but the ATC style devices are more versatile and lightweight. ATC threads on MP, some with actual content. May 30, 2023 · 358 Likes, 33 Comments. The Petzl Grigri The original Petzl Grigri was released in 1991 and it revolutionized the art of belaying for rock climbing. With assisted braking technology similar to a Grigri, this device ensures smooth and secure control during belaying and rappelling. Others have their preferences for similar designs from other brands, but I am pretty confident more mountains have been climbed with the ATC guide than any other. I had no problem with my belayers having either an ATC or an assisted braking device such as Grigri, ATC pilot etc as long as the belayer feels safe and competent. See full list on outdoorgearlab. Comments 196 Description Petzl NEOX vs Petzl GRIGRI what you need to know 1. Mar 2, 2023 · GriGri and ATC differ in functionalities, features, and other information. TikTok video from American Alpine Institute (@alpine_institute): “#GriGri vs ATC - #climbing #climber #rockclimbing #rockclimbingtiktok #climb #tradclimbing #outdoorclimbing #gymclimbing #mountaineering #iceclimbing #alpineclimbing #multipitch”. 0 beats out the Black Diamond ATC Pilot in all categories except for the package size on the harness, and would be my recommended choice for any climber looking for an added layer of security in case of an injury of the belayer at a lower weight and price point than a grigri. Sep 5, 2021 · 3) Wet/frozen ropes can be a nightmare to rap down when using a grigri so it helps to have a way to add friction to the system to make the descent smoother Grigris really aren't any heavier when you compare it to having to bring 2 carabiners and an atc on multipitch climbs. Accordingly, lots of climbers in the market for a belay device wonder whether to buy a GriGri or an ATC. The Posts about atc vs grigri written by The Climbing Majority Podcast Sep 29, 2022 · Keywords: ATC vs GriGri, climbing safety gear, differences between ATC and GriGri, do I need ATC or GriGri, climb safely, ATC vs GriGri comparison, climbing equipment, climbing gear, climbing devices This information is AI generated and may return results that are not relevant. I’ve started carrying my Petzl GriGri on multi-pitch trad routes for a multitude of reasons since it greatly simplifies rope ascension in a rescue scenario but also works great for hauling bags on big wall. But does it outperform the Grigri? The Grigri is a belay device. I'm curious about the safety differences between these devices. Jun 20, 2018 · Interested in the Petzl Grigri 2 belay device? Our in-depth review breaks down the pros and cons and compares it to the GriGri +. Phil and Chris delve into the question: What reigns supreme, the classic ATC by Black Diamond or the innovative GriGri by Petzl? Free Climbing Community: / climbclearacademy In this video I covered the difference when learning to belay with a GriGri vs. 2KLikes 110,043Views Jun 32024 Aug 24, 2018 · Belay devices are experiencing a renaissance of sorts, with more innovative options on the market than ever. GriGri vs tubeGriGri vs. com Aug 21, 2018 · Think of them as a cross between a GriGri and an ATC. (Photo: Alex Ratson/Getty) Aug 6, 2021 · Not sure which belay device to get? We tested the Petzl GriGri 2 and Black Diamond ATC side-by-side to help you know which is right for you. Apr 6, 2023 · Do you need to do some improvised rope ascending? You don't need a designated waist and foot prusik cord. Grigri Apr 22, 2017 · We are taking these two puppies out for a spin today, since they are the top belay devices with auto locking features. 0 is a great choice. Learn the pros, cons, and best use cases for each rappelling descender in this expert gear review. When a sufficient force is applied to the live end such as in a fall, the device locks up and prevents an uncontrolled fall. 0, with the idea that it’s cheaper than a GRIGRI and “safer” than a normal ATC XP. ATC: The ATC is a versatile device suitable for a range of climbing styles. And, while there are many ways to belay and more devices then we will touch on here, we’ll be covering the two most common ways you’ve probably encountered: The Grigri and the ATC. It offers several features that many will see as improvements over the standard GriGri, including an anti-panic handle and two different modes for top-rope and lead belaying. Tubular ATC Belay Devices Black Diamond ATC Belay Device Check Price and Reviews On Amazon The classic tubular belay device. The danger with a GriGri really comes from lowering improperly. He writes: “Having been a die-hard fan of the…Grigri for more than 20 years, I now proclaim that after less than three months of using the Trango Vergo assisted braking belay and rappel device, I am officially a Nov 24, 2015 · In reply to forrestpock: Lead belaying in climbing gyms should definitely be done with GriGris and not ATC type devices. Grigri's vs ATCs: This really grinds my gears As someone who learned to lead belay using an ATC first, and who for a while felt much more comfortable using an ATC over a Grigri, all climbers should be more comfortable using a Grigri. The main difference is The grigri/atc debate comes down the the argument that a component belayer doesn’t need a brake assist. Black Diamond ATC Guide best practices vs. What do you use, and why? Do you have different systems for belaying from the top versus bottom? Extended belay or not? I have lots of belay experience with regular grigri's and ATC's but I want to get my own grigri. It has been amazing. vfwgxdkeywyzjfemfywwaefprqgvqrhnkxqvhwcbhwozqinezuxncffexxgkghmkvh